Advocates say Illinois could approve gay marriage

2012-11-18T22:00:00Z Advocates say Illinois could approve gay marriageThe Associated Press The Associated Press
November 18, 2012 10:00 pm  • 

CHICAGO — Emboldened by recent victories at the polls and what they see as rapidly shifting attitudes in favor of gay rights, supporters say Illinois is ready to become the next state to allow same-sex marriage — though they acknowledge it won't be easy, even with Democratic majorities in Springfield.

Voters in four states either supported gay marriage or opposed a ban on it on Election Day — a sweep that state Rep. Greg Harris, the prime sponsor of a bill introduced in the Illinois House, said represents "a sea change" in public opinion. Those results, along with recent polling that shows support among an increasing number of Illinois voters, has Harris and other advocates counting votes and trying to determine not if legislation could get passed, but how soon.

The earliest anything could happen is during the veto session that starts next week or the waning days of the post-election lame duck session in early January. Or, supporters could wait until after the new session starts Jan. 9 — when Democrats will have supermajorities in the House and the Senate and a governor who has said he would sign the bill into law.

"We want to do it whenever we have the votes," said Rick Garcia, director of the Equal Marriage Illinois Project. "If we can do it in the veto session, we will. Otherwise we'll wait until spring."

But the political realities in Springfield mean ending Illinois' 16-year-old law banning same-sex marriage isn't a slam dunk, in the next few weeks or next session.

Because gay rights are not strict party-line issues, a Democratic majority doesn't automatically mean the bill will pass. When the General Assembly approved civil unions for same-sex couples during the lame duck session in 2010, 17 Democrats — most from central and southern Illinois — voted no, while six Republicans said yes. The bill passed the House by just two votes and the Senate by just one, though Democrats had larger majorities in the House and Senate than they do now.

Lawmakers will have a slate of urgent issues competing for their time and political capital, from fixing the nation's worst pension shortfall to a major budget crisis. Legislative leaders will have to weigh how moving gay marriage to the floor will affect those issues, and when the timing might be best.

And as they did with civil unions, opponents will be actively fighting any effort to change the law.

The Catholic Conference of Illinois, which opposes same-sex civil unions or marriage, is distributing a toolkit to churches and schools that outlines the church's position that marriage between a man and a woman is what's best for society, and that anything else would undermine the sanctity of such unions.

In 2011, the organization created a new Defense of Marriage Department to lead the charge against changing state laws, and they are lobbying lawmakers.

"There obviously has been some kind of change (in public opinion). What it means and where it's going in Illinois is yet to be seen," said Zach Wichmann, who heads the department. "We have a position, and that isn't changing."

Supporters say allowing gay marriage would provide practical benefits that same-sex couples don't get from civil unions, and that marriage is a much more commonly understood term than civil union. It's also a matter of principle.

"There should be one set of rules for everybody," Garcia said.

Peter Breen is an attorney for the Thomas More Society, who is representing two downstate county clerks who are defending the state's gay marriage ban against a lawsuit filed by 25 gay couples. Breen believes same-sex marriage proponents are over-stating the significance of the Nov. 6 ballot measures, which he says were in left-leaning states — Maine, Maryland, Minnesota and Washington — and where gay rights advocates outspent opponents on political advertising.

"There is no great change as a nation on this issue," he said.

Advocates hope to prove him wrong.

They note that President Barack Obama came out in support of gay marriage earlier this year — a position that didn't seem to hurt his re-election bid — and Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel recently said it should be one of the state's top legislative priorities.

In September, a poll for Southern Illinois University's Paul Simon Public Policy Institute found 44 percent of those polled said they believe gay and lesbian couples "should be allowed to legally marry." That's a 10-point increase from 2010, when only 34 percent backed gay marriage in a poll by the same institute.

On Election Day, voters in Lake County elected the state's fourth openly gay lawmaker, Democrat Sam Yingling, over Rep. Sandy Cole, R-Grayslake — who voted against the civil unions bill. And in exit polls conducted for the Associated Press a majority of voters in Illinois said the state should legally recognize same-sex marriages.

Add the four victories in other states, and Harris says the signs are undeniable.

"A lot of folks were saying, 'Wait to see how the election turns out,'" he said. "Elections do matter, and they show trends, and they can't be ignored."

Copyright 2015 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(1) Comments

  1. Freebird
    Report Abuse
    Freebird - November 18, 2012 11:23 pm
    Lookout, every time the state brings this issue up they slip something else through while the people are all arguing about it
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Anti-strike measure approved in House

SPRINGFIELD — Democrats in the Illinois House pushed through a plan Friday that could stop a lockout or a strike by the state's largest employ…

2 hours ago Related (0)

Summer Reading Programs

Anne West Lindsey District Library: 600 N. Division St., Carterville. Summer Reading registration will be June 1 through 6 during regular libr…

2 hours ago(0)
Marion police seeking runaway teen

Marion police seeking runaway teen

Marion Police Department is seeking help in searching for a reported runaway. 

10 hours ago(0)
Rauner wants compromise by Sunday

Rauner wants compromise by Sunday

SPRINGFIELD — Hoping to salvage some of his business-friendly agenda, Gov. Bruce Rauner said he wants to strike a deal with Democrats on issue… Updated: 11:26 pm

10 hours ago Photos


Related (0)

1st positive test for West Nile virus in Illinois in 2015

SPRINGFIELD — The state Department of Public Health reported the first positive test for West Nile virus this year has been reported in a batc…

10 hours ago(0)

Rauner: No special session if deadline for budget missed

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (AP) — Gov. Bruce Rauner says he will not call lawmakers back into session if there's no agreement on a budget by Sunday.

13 hours ago(0)
'Clean energy' bills take back seat to Illinois budget

'Clean energy' bills take back seat to Illinois budget

SPRINGFIELD — Measures advertised as promoting "clean energy" in Illinois — including a plan pushed by power-producing giant Exelon Corp. — ha… Updated: 10:03 pm

13 hours ago Photos


Related (0)

Rauner, leaders negotiating, but no budget deal this session

SPRINGFIELD — Illinois legislative leaders say they're still open to negotiating with Gov. Bruce Rauner over the 2016 budget and Rauner's pro-…

13 hours ago Related (0)

Updated: SIUE says worker killed repaving campus road

EDWARDSVILLE — A construction worker killed while repaving a road on the campus of Southern Illinois University Edwardsville has been identifi…

14 hours ago Related (0)

Carbondale man sentenced to eight years for heroin distribution

A Carbondale man was sentenced Tuesday in Jackson County court to eight years in prison for distributing heroin, according to a release from t… Updated: 10:03 pm

15 hours ago Related (0)
Activate subscription button gif
Follow the Southern Illinoisan