Fracking, donations and making legislation

Opponents say process is tainted
2013-03-24T00:45:00Z 2013-05-24T15:20:49Z Fracking, donations and making legislationBY NICK MARIANO, The Southern The Southern
March 24, 2013 12:45 am  • 

The energy and natural resources sector was among leading 2012 campaign contributors to area state representatives including the chief sponsor of proposed regulations to govern a controversial oil and gas extraction process known as fracking.

So, too, were contributions from labor.

Much of the combined contributions from energy came from oil and gas donors, some of which are headquartered outside of Illinois, although they may conduct business in the state.

State Reps. John Bradley, D-Marion; Mike Bost, R-Murphysboro; and Brandon Phelps, D-Harrisburg, combined to receive more than $100,000 from the energy sector while seeking re-election in 2012, according to the National Institute on Money in State Politics.

Bradley received $77,800 for his 2012 candidacy from energy and natural resources, second only to labor’s $110,069. Within the energy sector, oil and gas was the largest contributor, giving $47,250.

The energy sector was the leading contributor to Bost’s campaign that year, taking in $31,350, almost twice as that of the second leading contributor. Oil and gas made up $6,000 of that total.

Phelps campaign took in $38,050 from energy, $8,300 of which came from oil and gas.

The institute is a self-described nonpartisan, nonprofit group “dedicated to accurate, comprehensive and unbiased documentation and research on campaign finance at the state level,” according to its website:

Legislators: We’re clean

Bradley, the chief sponsor who introduced a fracking regulatory bill last month, and Bost, a participant in nearly 10-months of talks to get to this point, scoffed at the contributions as having any influence on them.

Phelps only recently signed on to HB2615 as a sponsor.

“I’m very careful about ethics and potential conflicts of interest,” Bradley said. “I stayed away from that issue (fracking) until the summer of 2012 when I was concerned the regulation would not be suffi-cient to protect the groundwater and to protect the areas of the state that I care about, which is South-ern Illinois.”

As Friday showed, the allegiance among legislators, oil and gas interests and some environmental groups can be complicated and even fragile.

Late last week, Bradley introduced a third amendment that would require Illinois well-water licensing, a move regarded as providing jobs for local union workers.

While oil and gas were big contributors to his campaign, so too was labor, giving him in excess of $110,000.

Oil and gas representatives involved in drafting the bill are upset with the amendment, saying it will require more negotiating. They remain committed to the bill as introduced last month.

Bost called the amendment a moratorium on fracking and said should the bill pass with the amendment, it could potentially kill any prospect of fracking occurring in Illinois until the political climate is more in their favor.

“All these jobs are going to go by the wayside,” Bost said. “There will be nobody to blame but, once again, the government of the state of Illinois. … We’re going to be broke and we’re going to continue to be broke.”

As for the campaign contributions, he too was dismissive.

The contributors ranged from individual, local geologists to out-of-state corporations with multiple oil and gas related operations and interests that may or may not include fracking.

“I support this because of jobs. I don’t support it because of a campaign contribution. … There are many groups and organizations (across sectors) that have given me money over the years. We have to run our campaigns. They cost money,” Bost said.

Bradley and Bost each also point out that the regulatory bill has been widely touted as containing the strongest fracking rules in the nation, a statement made by others involved in talks including some environmental groups.

SAFE’s reaction

Reaction to the campaign contributions from fracking opponents was mixed when reached last week, ranging from reluctant acceptance because of a plagued political system when it comes to money to outright condemnation of what was described as a clear conflict of interest.

“I believe that the oil and gas industry’s campaign contributions to Rep. Bradley do affect his ability to keep an open mind about the dangers of fracking,” said Vito Mastrangelo,” a member of the legal team for Southern Illinoisans Against Fracking the Environment.

A second SAFE legal team member, Richard Fedder, was not as harsh, saying the legislators have done what every other politician does. Instead, he blamed a broken political system fed by campaign contributions.

Where Fedder did come down hard was on the proposed regulatory bill for what he described as significant gaps in protecting the environment and health of Southern Illinoisans.

While he acknowledges that the proposed rules would hold the industry more accountable than anywhere else in the country, “being strict does not make regulations safe.”

Proponents point to months of negotiations on fracking regulation and input from a wide range of environmental groups.

Fedder, however, said some in those groups are more interested in compromise than in representing the environmental concerns of the region where most fracking would occur. SAFE, he said, was not included in discussions on the legislation.

While negotiations on new legislation are to continue, it does not matter to SAFE. The only General Assembly action their members support is a moratorium on fracking, Fedder said.

“We oppose (the bill) whichever way those debates come out,” Fedder said. “The bill is flawed for many reasons.”

Several environmental groups represented in talks, including the National Resource Defense Council, the Environmental Law and Policy Center and others have maintained they prefer a moratorium but should a halt not be enacted, it is better to be at the table to establish rules than not be.


Copyright 2015 The Southern. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(4) Comments

  1. samspade597
    Report Abuse
    samspade597 - March 25, 2013 9:57 am
    Haha, why should SAFE or any other privately funded organization have to disclose sources? Conflicts? There aren't any conflicts They are not relying on taxpayer dollars and do not represent the public. Bost and others are paid by us... taxpayers. We do not have a choice, we are forced to pay the salaries of these public officials and they are supposed to represent us. Therefore, we are entitled to know who is funding their campaigns.
  2. wendelin
    Report Abuse
    wendelin - March 24, 2013 5:32 pm
    It is he who greases the hand that gets the most votes.
    I have worked with fracking in southern and eastern US,
    How can this bill not be passed, more jobs, more production. All will have a bigger bank account.
    Till you get the facts, get them, it will suprise you what fracking will do for production.
  3. ShawneeHollar
    Report Abuse
    ShawneeHollar - March 24, 2013 11:34 am
    I'll tell you where SAFE's funding comes from. Mostly, their own pockets, and small donations from T-shirt sales and events they hold. Also...SAFE has memebers in Saline, Pope, Hardin, and many other Southeastern IL counties.
  4. Ox Bird
    Report Abuse
    Ox Bird - March 24, 2013 10:09 am
    While politicians are required to disclose donor funds, is it possible that other participants in this issue are funded by interested parties?

    Is it possible that certain environmental groups are being funded by oil and gas interests who have existing production assets which would be less valuable if additional production from Southern Illinois came into the market?

    It is interesting to note that none of the major participants in the "local" anti-fracking efforts are actually residents of Southeastern Illinois.....the area that might have commercially viable potential for oil/gas wells of this sort. The "locals" come from places like Carbondale, Makanda, Mt. Vernon, Il. and Monticello, Il. What makes them "care" so deeply about places like Fairfield, Carmi and Eldorado?

    Some of these people seem to be very well-qualified. They are professional folks and when they deal with these issues, they are not working in unfamiliar fields.

    It's a shame that they are not required to disclose their sources of funding and any conflicts which they might have.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Illinois Senate advances plan to increase school funding

SPRINGFIELD — An Illinois Senate committee has advanced legislation to increase funding for education this year to a level first proposed by G… New

25 minutes ago Related (0)
Democrats push 1-month budget; Rauner, GOP likely to oppose

Democrats push 1-month budget; Rauner, GOP likely to oppose

SPRINGFIELD — Democrats pushed Wednesday for a one-month spending plan they said would allow critical services to continue as Illinois enters … Updated: 11:39 am

44 minutes ago Photos


Related (0)
Watch: Carbondale mom and daughter dance video goes viral

Watch: Carbondale mom and daughter dance video goes viral

CARBONDALE — Jaylyn Gregory has got some serious moves — and now the world knows it. Updated: 10:55 am

1 hour ago Related (0)

Rauner borrows from special state funds to manage cash flow

SPRINGFIELD — Gov. Bruce Rauner has borrowed $454 million from special state funds to help manage cash flow as Illinois begins a new fiscal ye… Updated: 11:39 am

1 hour ago Related (0)

Rauner budget chief: Dems' spending plan 'unconstitutional'

SPRINGFIELD — Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner's budget director says a one-month spending plan proposed by Democrats is "unconstitutional" becaus… Updated: 11:39 am

3 hours ago Related (0)
Injured Marine hand-pedaling cross-country to raise funds for military organization

Injured Marine hand-pedaling cross-country to raise funds for military organization

CARBONDALE — Jack and Lori McCabe were watching the news around 4:30 a.m. Tuesday near St. Louis when they learned that a U.S. Marine veteran … Updated: 9:53 am

5 hours ago Photos


Sales tax increase takes effect in Carbondale

Sales tax increase takes effect in Carbondale

CARBONDALE — For the second time in as many years, sales tax in Carbondale is on the rise. Updated: 10:12 am

6 hours ago Photos


Related (0)
Four bids received for Grand Tower levee work

Four bids received for Grand Tower levee work

GRAND TOWER — A Marion company that made the lowest bid to repair levees in Grand Tower and Degognia/Fountain Bluffs will likely be recommende…

7 hours ago Photos


Related (0)

Missing 13-year-old Illinois girl found near overnight camp

Searchers have found a 13-year-old girl who went missing for more than a day after a taxi dropped her off at a Southern Illinois overnight camp.

11 hours ago(0)
Carbondale mayor pulls residency requirement item from council agenda

Carbondale mayor pulls residency requirement item from council agenda

CARBONDALE — There was no discussion of residency requirements for Carbondale’s top city employees Tuesday night at the Carbondale City Counci… Updated: 10:37 am

11 hours ago Photos


Related (0)
Activate subscription button gif
Follow the Southern Illinoisan


Deals & Offers